ThothII/docs/testing/evidence/evidence-restructuring-psd-acceptance-2026-08-25.md

PSD Evidence restructuring — real acceptance

Date and completion time: 2026-08-25T21:44:26Z (UTC)
Reviewer: Marco Pancotti
Human Git review: PASS
Scope: issues #47 and parent #35

The reviewer approved all 35 proposed Evidence and authorized resolution of all 60 review items. The accepted rules were: retain domain when fully qualified identifiers are absent; invent no schema, table, column, or value; mark incomplete lists as non-exhaustive; preserve caveats and ambiguities; consolidate examples into one unit per source; treat N=5 as a recommendation rather than a mandatory limit; and interpret "SEF seguito da ablazione" as a later event in time.

Source and recovery record

• ThothII implementation candidate 66f9fa2821decf30bec4468a33a499d8ea459510 and Linux deployment repairs d49c644b611a7cc50f19fd40f30464ec0a12d2db and e51a6a22535de934c9245068994a3eaf3e855f96 and 12d257056fe8293d1f0e4e3e613feba41c5f76a7 and 287ce91e67ce736804656819401f9ba474406e63 and 73efeb7f3d3f3de487f2686a2074c0953c9d51e4 and 2b6bb058d8151a76919bf1bde94d304af646f8b4 and a3259ced99f981b4a18924b1149d27471f1a5e45 and 0df95e337ec4a492891ae3f523c3a28aa88e67cb and 8b524b4314856b8b4eaa8629c3466fd382ea3357 and 663c60dc3e5d456b65c4b195e2951b271438c147 and 9a62fce1add42339d79c6a0f919fb7ab6f5fabea and a0620ffffa87f38ba663cd4a20fbf8d516a166f5 (PR #48).
• PSD authoring review: PR #2, head c93174841da253512ab81b32cf8c68304bc02e31, merged as 07ae6930a21299082685d2b3668912ac2d188079.
• Canonical-root correction: PR #3, head 93c4b9a3189eb3113bb5d2d0b313332c064e1a1b, merged as a4b27c6fe1cf41aac8102933a4100da8fee345e6.
• Atomic-unit retention: PR #4, head 384f76a11d1e705b41d9df785337f81bc7515e2d, merged as the published PSD revision 1c304efa02547a4c10826f557376a38e959b8bbf.
• Pre-migration Qdrant snapshot: psd-clinical-6759909623621226-2026-08-25-18-43-21.snapshot, 28,121,600 bytes, SHA-256 da7fdf114fdd1a638eb6f828ac127126258451dc617e8d409b5895bfd15397a6. It is retained for collection-level rollback; no collection was deleted or renamed.

Command output and durable runtime records are in:

• this report and docs/testing/evidence-restructuring-manual.md;
• /data/sessions/psd-clinical/preprocessing/jobs/44bedc056f256d983ce88b9a565d9fd6.json (dry run) and /data/sessions/psd-clinical/preprocessing/jobs/c564d7fdb36436b3ae76dc0c2ce1e20d.json (publication);
• /data/sessions/psd-clinical/corpus/ACTIVE and /data/sessions/psd-clinical/corpus/gen-f968808223bf462fa406c9a6df8f6a55/manifest.json;
• /data/sessions/psd-clinical/sessions/20301df7-cb3c-421a-b14f-dec8cf8d9620/ for the real walkthrough artifacts.

No secret, patient identifier, payload, or vector is copied into this report.

Manual acceptance results

1. Authoring and Git review — PASS. Exactly 35 source documents were migrated and validated into 35 curated units (34 domain, 1 glossary), with one unit per source, zero remaining review items, zero validation findings, stable evidence:<slug> IDs, and no automatic orphan deletion. psd-clinical/evidence/README.md remains present. PR #2 records the human-reviewed content; PRs #3 and #4 are path/policy corrections without semantic invention.

2. Additive BM25 upgrade — PASS. The existing psd-clinical collection and unnamed 1,024-dimensional cosine dense vector were preserved. The only vector-schema addition is sparse vector bm25 with modifier idf. There was no rebuild, dense-vector rename, fallback engine, or collection replacement.

3. Schema and Memory non-regression — PASS. Immediately before and after Evidence publication the protected counts remained 163 schema_table, 2,275 schema_column, 2 memory, and 1 solved_question; the saved representative IDs and repeated dense Schema/Memory neighbors were unchanged. The later real walkthrough intentionally promoted two approved memories and one solved question, so the final live counts are 4 and 2 while all baseline IDs remain present. The 35-unit migration itself did not modify those families.

4. Inactive candidate, evaluation, activation — PASS. Dry run 44bedc056f256d983ce88b9a565d9fd6 completed without activation. Publication run c564d7fdb36436b3ae76dc0c2ce1e20d built child f968808223bf462fa406c9a6df8f6a55 as an inactive candidate, evaluated that exact generation, then activated gen:f968808223bf462fa406c9a6df8f6a55. It contains 35 documents and 35 chunks; the run reported 35 changed and 36 legacy removals from the active set. All 20 evaluation queries passed Hit@10. Representative diagnostic ranks were:

   Profile	Query	Dense	BM25	Fused
   lexical	lexical-chirone-meta	1	1	1
   semantic	semantic-controllo-device	1	1	1
   mixed	mixed-deduplica-codici	7	5	2

   The previous generation gen:f91ccc1ae1dc4ccab05e7d70a7675a97 is retained. The live collection has 78 Evidence points (43 retained older points plus the 35 active-generation points); generation filtering, rather than destructive deletion, determines publication.

5. Hybrid and Formula retrieval — PASS. The contract suite proves dense and BM25 receive the identical NFC-normalized, newline-preserving, outer-trim-only query. The isolated acceptance fixture accepts a PostgreSQL expression, rejects a full query, and retrieves an approved formula through its typed Evidence path. No PSD formula was invented for this migration. The real session persisted concept_formulas: [] and evidence.json: [], so its proposals remain unpublished.

6. Empty versus unavailable — PASS. The acceptance probe recorded an available empty retrieval that may continue and a controlled unavailable-Qdrant retrieval that blocks the stage. The unavailable path used neither stale generation nor purpose fallback.

7. Complete real session — PASS. Session 20301df7-cb3c-421a-b14f-dec8cf8d9620, named Accettazione Evidence #47 — SEF seguito da ablazione, ran with zai/glm-5.3 through clarification, rewriting, schema linking, three executed CTEs, final SQL, and finalization. It used the approved interpretation of two distinct events in 2024 and the temporal predicate ablazione > SEF; all three CTE executions returned ok. The approved read-only SQL has SHA-256 b26d26c9c1e8579d7e3d5ccabe874e02b570bc15cfbe1b2ce822c28ae8b0e2ac, parsed without warnings, and returned 78 patients. Five independently persisted Evidence receipts cover clarification/disambiguation, rewriting, schema linking, CTE/SQL generation, and final SQL, all bound to gen:f968808223bf462fa406c9a6df8f6a55. Memory and synthesis did not invoke Evidence search. The authenticated UI showed the finalized session to Local Admin. The abandoned provider preflight session was archived without deletion.

Automated verification

• bash scripts/evidence-restructuring-acceptance.sh: Evidence acceptance contracts PASS.
• Backend Vitest: 78 files passed, 1 skipped; 1,119 tests passed, 40 skipped; TypeScript PASS.
• Frontend Vitest and TypeScript PASS.
• Harness: 1,103 tests passed, 4 deselected; Ruff PASS.
• Go: 19 packages, zero failures.
• Task 13 runtime fixtures: local PASS; server PASS; shell syntax PASS. The server regression proves both the root-owned canonical store and the UID/GID 10001:10001 runtime projection are created with mode 0700 before OIDC configuration.

manual acceptance: PASS