Files
ThothII/docs/reports/knowledge-archives-release.md
2026-09-15 14:37:29 +02:00

4.4 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

Knowledge archives: consolidated implementation evidence

Consolidated on 15 September 2026 from the M1–M3, E1–E3 and X1 records of 8–9 September. This is historical verification evidence, not a claim that these test counts describe today's tree or that every installation has passed acceptance. Original commands, detailed outcomes and local deployment details remain under docs/plans/ in Git commit 5f3a7f5975b96fae1e1cdd0da08b4d60d41064cc.

Increment Delivered boundary Recorded verification
M1 PostgreSQL Memory authority, administration, durable indexing retry 1,134 harness + 9 portable cases; 17 real PostgreSQL/Qdrant cases; 190 Pi gates; 632 frontend. One backend auth timeout passed its isolated rerun.
M2 Dense/BM25 recall, scoped links and explicit projection rebuild 1,152 harness; 78 targeted cases with real embedding; 13 Fastify API cases; 10 wheel/CLI cases.
M3 Human Memory promotion, receipts and physical-schema dependency cleanup 1,152 harness + 9 portable; 41 Memory integration, 1 optional embedding skipped, 1 L2 excluded; 195 Pi gates; 635 frontend; 5 Catalog integration. Backend timing case passed isolated rerun.
E1 Editable file authority and explicit consolidation 1,180 harness + 9 portable; real Qdrant including optional 35-unit PSD probe. No actual PSD authoring checkout conversion in E1.
E2 Evidence administration, host CLI and pending activation recovery 1,355 backend, 639 frontend, 1,248 harness; portable-path rerun passed with THT_HOME unset. Initial authenticated visual acceptance remained manual.
E3 Draft import, explicit source refresh and protected manual corrections 1,359 backend, 641 frontend, 1,256 harness; 24 focused checks. Synthetic filesystem/HTTP/S3 behavior, not a live S3-account certification.
X1 Human-reviewed Memory/Evidence conflict correction and durable recovery 1,264 harness + 9 portable; 1,366 backend, 645 frontend, 199 Pi gates; desktop/mobile widget probe and later real authenticated administration probe.

X1's configured zai/glm-5.3 probe used synthetic conflicting knowledge. It was not a full autonomous Pi-session certification or acceptance of PSD semantics. Later administration checks exercised real authentication and a disposable synthetic workspace, including persistence across backend restart. Existing PSD archive content was not rewritten by those probes.

Current authorities and repeatable checks

Do not equate passing synthetic tests with real-provider quality, live S3 coverage, PSD-domain acceptance or permission to migrate another installation. Those remain explicit operator gates.

Catalog/model design records consolidated at the same time

The old metadata-catalog exploration and description-generation plan/spec are no longer current-state authorities. PostgreSQL/Fastify ownership, installation bindings, description generation and source-sampling constraints now live in ADRs 0001–0016, architecture, Database Management and the description acceptance checklist. The installation-model plan is replaced by ADR 0013 and the current model catalog guide.

Preserve these outstanding questions rather than infer acceptance from implementation: real provider/DWH acceptance recorded by the owner, licensing review of shipped optional models, future dialect/multi-schema support, and any desired semantic aliases/value descriptions. The former proposed catalog-to-core cutover and separate database permissions are already represented by current ADR 0016 and database.manage; do not reopen them as unfinished steps. The original description-generation plan referred to issue #4 for final delivery gates; this consolidation neither changes nor closes its tracker state.